Which Account Should You Tap First in Retirement? Understanding Withdrawal Sequencing

March 13, 2024

Navigating the retirement landscape can be daunting, especially when deciding which account to withdraw from first. Whether retirees should tap into taxable, tax-deferred, or Roth accounts first is crucial for optimizing financial stability in retirement. In a discussion, Amy Arnott and Roger Young shed light on the complexities and strategies behind withdrawal sequencing, emphasizing the importance of tailored approaches.

Roger Young highlights the intricate nature of planning retirement withdrawals, mentioning, “It’s not easy, I will tell you that. I’ve done a good amount of work on it.” He points out the collaboration with T. Rowe Price’s newly acquired company, Retiree, Inc., which has developed software to assist retirees in strategizing their withdrawal and Social Security-claiming decisions. Young elaborates on the dynamic strategies that can be applied at different retirement phases, from leveraging low tax brackets early on to navigating required minimum distributions and tax implications later in retirement.

Christine Benz brings to the forefront a common logistical concern among retirees: whether to roll over funds from a 401(k) to an IRA upon retirement. Young discusses the various factors influencing this decision, highlighting the flexibility and investment options an IRA offers compared to a 401(k). However, he acknowledges the potential benefits of staying within a 401(k) plan, such as lower investment fees and the familiarity and education plan sponsors provide.

The conversation also touches upon the challenge of required minimum distributions (RMDs), with Young noting legislative changes like the Secure Act, which delayed RMDs to age 73. He offers strategies for mitigating the tax impact of RMDs, including early withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts, qualified charitable distributions, and investing in a qualified longevity annuity contract (QLAC) to delay RMDs further.

The path to a financially secure retirement is multifaceted and deeply personal. Strategies for withdrawal sequencing and managing retirement accounts must be customized to individual circumstances, considering the evolving landscape of tax laws, life expectancy, and personal financial goals. As Roger Young and Christine Benz suggest, leveraging tools like retirement planning software and seeking professional advice can provide invaluable guidance in navigating these decisions. Retirees are encouraged to actively plan their withdrawal strategies to optimize their financial well-being in their golden years.

Latest from Retirement

withemes on instagram

[instagram-feed feed=1]